The Western accounts on early Albanian-Serbian interactions and the Kosovo myth

MA. Arben Salihu

Abstract


For most of the last millennium, the Balkan region, has been associated with conflicts, wars and instability. Indeed, even today, the situation is very tense. Finding the causes of it, is imperative, but that still does not resolve the deep divisions that are ingrained. The aim of this study is to explore what the Western literature reveals about Balkan enmities, more specifically Albanian-Serbian hostilities throughout past centuries, by focusing at certain periods or events that had a great impact in historical context. The study focuses extensively on Kosovo myth, but also on other specific episodes of Albanian- Serbian interaction, namely Serbian Empire, 1389 Kosovo battle, the description event of Murat I death, and 1806 Serbian Revolution among others. One must bear in mind that Albanians and Serbs presented a united front in certain battles and fights (namely in 1389 and 1806), but later turned guns against each other, resulting in thousands unnecessary deaths. This occurred not because their respective citizens wanted so, but was largely incited through government myths and insincere propaganda. Taking exclusively the Western perspective in this context, whose exploration of events in the Balkans is pretty detailed, only enriches the quality of this study. This research concludes that the region should and must learn from past mistakes that living with myths, wars and propaganda leads to nowhere. The Balkan more than ever needs proactive and creative leaders that shift the minds of Balkan people towards elimination, or at least diminishing, of both physical and mental boundaries against each other.


Keywords


Albania; Kosovo; Ottoman Empire; Murat I; Serbia; War;

References


‘Action By Greece In Albania. Impending Occupation Of Northern Epirus., Reasons For The Step.’,(1914), The Times, 27 October, p.7

Albrizzi G. (1685) L' Origine Del Danvbio, Volume 2, dietro la Chiesa di S. Zulian, Venetia

‘Austria is inflexible’, (1912), The New York Times, 11 November, p.2

Balkan Insight (2014) List of Kosovo War Victims Published in http://www.balkaninsight.com/en/article/kosovo-war-victims-list-published [Accessed 28 May 2017]

Bohun E. (1693), A geographical dictionary representing the present and antient names and states, Charles Breme, London

BouéA 1840,La Turquied'Europe, Vol II ,ArthusBartrand, Paris,p.32

Brewster D., (1832), The Edinburgh Encyclopaedia, Volume 1, Joseph and Edward Parker, Philadelphia

Brownell HH 1862, The Eastern or the Old World: Embracing ancient and modern history, Vol II, Hurlbut, Williams and Company, Hartford p.75

Calendar of the War: key Map of the states,’ 1912, The Times, 17 October , p.6

Catafago J. (1873) An English and Arabic Dictionary, Piccadilly, London

ChalcocondylesL. and de Vigenère B., (1577) L'Histoire de la décadence de l'Empiregrec et établissement de celuy des Turcs, Chez Nicolas Chesneau, Paris

Chambers, W. & R (1868) Chambers's Encyclopaedia: A Dictionary of Universal Knowledge for the people, Volume 8, W. and R. Chambers, London

Coleridge S. T. (1854) Encyclopaedia Metropolitana; or System of Universal Knowledge: History of the Ottoman Empire, Richard Griffin and Company, London

Cooke W.S. (1876) The Ottoman Empire and its tributary states (excepting Egypt), with a sketch of Greece, W Clowes and son, London

Cosic, D.,(1961), Deobe, Vol I, Prosveta, Belgrade, p.135

De Fontanieu G. M. A. (1733) Rosalinda - a novel, John Osborne, London

Droysens G. (1886) Allgemeiner historischer Hand atlas in sechsundneunzig Karten miterläuterndem Text, Velhagen & Klasing, Bielefeld

Elsie, R. (2011), Historical Dictionary of Kosovo, (Second Edition) Scarecrow Press, Inc, Lanham,

Fine J.V.A. (1991), The Early Medieval Balkans: A Critical Survey from the Sixth to the Late Twelfth Century, Michigan University Press, Michigan

Forbes N., Toynbee, A. J. Mitrany D., and Hogarth D. G., (1915) The Balkans: A history of Bulgaria, Serbia, Greece, Rumania, Turkey, Clarendon Press, Oxford

‘Food for Serbia and Montenegro’, (1915), The Times, 20 November, p.9

‘France. Servia’, 1879, The Times, 24 September, p.5

Gerhart, E. V. and Schaff, P. (1860). The Mercersburg Review, M. Kieffer& Co. Pittsburg, pp. 25-26

Gibbon E.,(1837) The history of the decline and fall of Roman empire, Harper and Brothers, New York

‘Greeks attack Albanians’ (1914), The New York Times, 4 April, p,.4

Hopf C., ed. (1873) Chroniquesgréco-romanesinéditesoupeuconnuespubliées avec notes et tables généalogiques, Librairie de Weidmann, Berlin

Jacob S., Procter C. Riddle J. E. and M’Conechy J. (1854) History of the Ottoman Empire, including a survey of the Greek Empire and the Crusades, Richard Griffib and Company, London

Jameson R., (1849) The Edinburgh New Philosophical Journal: Exhibiting a View of the progressive discoveries and improvements in the sciences and the arts, Volume 46, Green & Longmans, London

King R., Mai N., (2008) Out Of Albania: From Crisis Migration to Social Inclusion in Italy, Berghahn Books, New York,

‘Latest Intelligence. France’, 1878, The Times, 20 June, p.5

Latham R. G. (1863), The Nationalities of Europe, Volume 2, W H Allen and Co., London

‘Marching Through Serbia. Fate Of Nish And Monastir., Macedonian Refugees In Greece.’(1915), The Times, 3 November, p.10

Mignot V. (1773), Histoire de l'Empire Ottoman, Depuis son originejusqu'à la paix de Belgrade en 1740, Vol 1, Chez Le Clerc, Paris

Ranke, L. V. (1844). Die Serbische Revolution: Aus SerbischenPapieren und Mittheilungen, Duncker und Humblot, Berlin, p. 151.

Royal Anthropological Institute of Great Britain and Ireland (1879), Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute of Great Britain and Ireland, Trübner and Co. London

‘Serbs are killing Moslem thousands’, (1913), The New York Times, 18 January, p.1

Serbian Invasion of Albania: Fall of Durazzo Expected’,(1915) The Times, 17 June, p.7

‘Servia,’ 1876, The Times, 23 November p.5

‘Servia’, 1889, The Times, 14 October, p.6

‘Servian Army left a trail of blood’, (1912), The New York Times, 31 December, p.3

‘Serbia Under Invasion. A Journey South From Nish., Mountain Tracks Of Albania.’ (1915), The Times, 27 November, p.9

Shaw, A. (1901). The American Monthly Review of Reviews: An International Magazine, Volume 24, (July-December), Review of Reviews Company, New York.

Shepherd W. (1911) Historical Atlas. Henry Holt and Company, New York p. 73

Soranzo L., and von Heroldsberg J. G., (1601) Turca nikētos: hoc est, de imperio Ottomannico evertendo et bello contra Tvrcas Prospere gerendo, Consilia Tria Lectio, Claudium Marnium & Heredes Io, Aubrii

Stern I, (1912), Turkey Betrayed, The New York Times, 18 December, p.14

‘The Congress’, 1878, The Times 27 May, p.5

‘The Exodus Of Serbia. New Capital At Skutari.,Kossovo Abandoned.(1915)’The Times, 25 November, p.8

‘The Servians, 1878a, The Times, 16 January, p.5

‘The Servians’, 1878b, The Times, 28 January, p.5

‘The Servo-Turkish War, 1876, The New York Times, 20 August, p.1

‘The situation in Europe’,1880, The New York Times, 26 June, p.2

‘The War’, 1876a, The Times, 7 July, p.5

‘The War’, 1876b, The Times, 11 August, p.5

‘The War in Servia’, 1876, The Times, 12 July, p.9

‘The War. Servia’, 1876, The Times, 10 October, p.3 (Toplica)

‘The War. The Servian Army.’ The Times 1876, 3 August, p.9

Upham E. (1829) History of the Ottoman Empire from its establishment till the year 1828, Constable and Co., London

Vesti Online, (2015) ,Vučić o ubistvušestoricemladića u kafiću Panda, in http://www.vesti.rs/Vesti/Vucic-o-ubistvu-sestorice-mladica-u-kaficu-Panda.html [Accessed 28 May 2017]

Wiedeburg F. A. (1787), Humanistisches Magazin zur gemein nützlichen Unterhaltung, und insonderheit in Beziehung auf akademische Studien, Vol. 1, Helmstedt, Leipzig


Full Text: PDF

DOI: 10.21113/iir.v7i1.299

Article Metrics

Metrics Loading ...

Metrics powered by PLOS ALM

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.




Copyright (c) 2017 Arben Jetullah Salihu

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
x
Message